I closed the laptop, exhaled, and buried my face in my hands.
I can’t do this.
I stood up to go for a walk. Surely that will help.
It did not. I came back to my laptop with the same ideas, but now hot and profusely sweating because it’s August in Florida.
I brewed a cup of coffee. Surely that will help.
Again, it did not. But it did give me a touch of anxiety to add onto my dread of not knowing what to write!
Nearly 4 hours of staring at a blank screen, starting new Google Docs with ideas, only to leave them half finished.
That’s too vulnerable, I can’t share that!
That’s too boring, no one will read it!
Wtf am I even writing, this makes no sense!
It was nearly time to put my laptop away for the day so I could switch from tortured writer to mom mode for school pickup.
I felt like a failure. Nothing accomplished except a collection of scattered ideas.
As I sat with this feeling, it dawned on me that I was putting an enormous amount of pressure on myself to become this exceptional literary genius immediately, when in reality I just started writing again less than two months ago.
Sure, I was a content writer several years back, so I’m not a complete newbie to writing. But creative writing? I haven’t done that since college. And even then it was just one semester (why did I take a creative writing class for my PharmD degree? I don’t know, but regardless, I LOVED that class).
Unfortunately, I’m not new to the feeling of putting pressure on myself to be immediately good at something. It’s a pattern I keep repeating.
The worst part is that it makes me want to quit. My inner critic thrives on repeating the phrase “I can’t do this” over and over until I convince myself that it’s true.
Of course, it’s natural to feel frustrated when we cannot do something well at first. I’ve seen this play out on an almost daily basis with my 6-year-old. When he tries something new and struggles with it—let’s say, hitting a baseball—the range of emotions quickly escalates from frustration to anger to sadness. In his despair, he throws the baseball bat and cries, “I can’t do this!”
My response is always the same: “You’re really frustrated. You wanted to hit the ball, and it’s not working yet. It’s okay to be mad. You’re still learning. You can do anything if you keep practicing.”
I would never say to him: “Yes, you’re right, you can’t do it!”
So why is it okay to say that to myself?
Why do I put so much pressure on myself to be immediately good at something new? And when I feel frustrated or upset when it’s hard, I don’t give myself any grace whatsoever. Nada. Zip. Zilch. Might as well say to myself, “yep, you suck, you should probably just quit!”
Why do I do this?

The beginner gap
Whenever I’m examining my own behaviors like I’m examining a zit in the mirror, asking “where did you come from?” I turn to psychology and neuroscience for explanations.
In the case of putting pressure on myself to be good at something right away, psychology has quite a few explanations for why humans do this. I discovered that there are, in fact, so many different explanations that I began to regret my need to know these types of things.
Perfectionism. Achievement-based self-worth. All-or-nothing thinking. A low tolerance for uncertainty. The list goes on.
Instead of going down a rabbit hole like I did, just know this: if you’re putting pressure on yourself to be immediately good at something, you’re probably not allowing yourself to be a beginner.
When we start something new, we enter what I’m calling “the beginner gap”— the uncomfortable distance between how good we expect ourselves to be at something new and how good we actually are.
When you start something new and inevitably enter the beginner gap, you know what you want to accomplish. You know who you want to become. There’s a clear image in your mind of this potential. But then you’re faced with the humbling reality that getting to that point is not as easy as it looks.
Let’s use writing on Substack as an example.
Almost anyone can create a Substack and call themselves a writer. Everyone has a story to tell and the right to tell it.
Becoming a writer is easy. Becoming a great writer? Perhaps not so much. You have to come up with original ideas, capture and hold a reader’s attention, structure a compelling story, find your voice, etc. And, if you’re anything like me, you’ll also stare at a blank Google Doc wondering why the ideas in your mind can’t be translated into words on the screen.
And therein lies the beginner gap.
I want to write something great now. But wanting to write something great and having the experience to consistently do so are two very different things.
This is the exact scenario I found myself in earlier when I was staring at a blank Google Doc for hours, desperately hoping that a long walk or at least caffeine would save me.
The beginner gap can be infuriating. You can see where you want to be, but you can’t seem to get there fast enough. So you apply more pressure. And when more pressure doesn’t produce better results, you apply even more. Eventually, the pressure becomes so loud that your inner critic starts relentlessly telling you to quit.
You must not listen. Do not quit while you’re in the beginner gap. Your inner critic might tell you that you should be farther along by now, that you’re not good enough, that maybe you just don’t have what it takes. So what? Let it talk. You don’t have to believe it.
I came across a tip from author Nir Eyal to set a checkpoint before you start something new. Choose a date in the future and commit to sticking with your new endeavor until that date. Then, and only then, decide whether to continue.
I think this is helpful because it prevents you from quitting simply because of the discomfort of being a beginner. It also prevents you from pushing through something that isn’t working or isn’t right for you. Don’t push through the beginner gap if you don’t enjoy what you’re doing; that will just lead to a miserable life.
It’s okay if you suck at first
If you do want to become great at something, you’ll likely have to go through the beginner gap. Surprisingly, the way out of this frustrating scenario is actually learning to tolerate it. Sorry, I don’t have any profound answers for you. There’s no shortcut or technique out of it.
You have to learn to tolerate being a beginner. To let yourself be bad at something without turning that into a judgment about yourself.
When your inner critic is raging and saying things like “You should be farther along than you are right now!”, instead of putting pressure on yourself to try to get better, pretend like you’re talking to a child.
Imagine putting a baseball in front of a six-year-old, watching him miss three pitches, and saying, “Wow. You’re really not a natural at this. Maybe baseball just isn’t your thing.”
Obviously, that’s ridiculous.
We’d tell the six-year-old that it’s okay that he can’t do it yet, he just started. We’d tell him to “practice, practice, practice” if he wanted to get better. And the same goes for you.
I believe that’s the true measure of success. Practice. Devotion. Consistency. Showing up even when your inner critic is telling you that you should be farther along.
The antidote to the pressure to be immediately good at something is simple: Be willing to be bad at it long enough to become good.
x
K
If you enjoyed this essay, consider buying me a coffee ☕️ Writing takes time, and your support helps me keep making space for it. Thanks for being here🤍



that baseball example is painfully accurate... i'd give the kid ten times more patience than i'd give myself
I started my Substack a couple of weeks ago and boy am I in the beginner gap! I so enjoyed this piece. Short (related) story, I started riding horses 20 years ago as an absolute beginner and just now would I consider myself a competent rider. I was only good at one thing: showing up.